Club 54 Has The Mens Clothing You Need
Three near-perfect fits and one oversized miss make for Club 54's strongest month yet.
Five Four took a chance with the mismatched color sleeves and it totally paid off.
Our reviewer3 of 4 Ain't Bad
Club 54's second box outperformed the first, with three of four pieces landing as genuine hits. The Timor Jacket led the pack — warm without overheating in a mild climate, casual enough for daily wear yet sharp enough for a date, and cut with the rare combination of a trim midsection and properly long sleeves.
The William Zip-Up Hoodie took a stylistic risk with mismatched sleeve colors that paid off, delivering soft, form-fitting comfort exactly where a plain dark hoodie was missing from the rotation. The Robert Geller Yosemite Joggers surprised as well, fitting perfectly and offering more mobility than older sweatpants, even if street-wearing them still felt like a stretch.
The one clear miss was the Robben Short Sleeve Shirt, sized for a frame roughly twice as large, with room in the stomach for two people and a length that ran nearly to the knees.
Even with one swing and a miss, the month was a clear win. The jacket and hoodie alone justified the box, and the value still beat shopping in stores.
Why We Love It
- Timor Jacket looked great and kept warm without overheating, dressy enough for a date
- William Zip-Up Hoodie's mismatched sleeve colors worked, with soft, comfortable cotton
- Robert Geller Yosemite Joggers fit perfectly and added extra mobility
- Even with one miss, still cheaper than shopping in stores
Considerations
- Robben Short Sleeve Shirt ran roughly twice too large, with room for two in the stomach and a length near the knees
- Sweatpants-style joggers felt like a style risk our reviewer wasn't sure about wearing in public
Unboxing Box #2
The Timor Jacket solved a fit problem our reviewer called chronically hard to find — thin waist, long arms — with sleeves the right length and still enough room at the stomach for thicker builds.
The William Zip-Up Hoodie's two-tone sleeves stood out from an all-dark hoodie rotation, and the cotton stayed soft and warm. The Yosemite Joggers were comfortable enough to wear around the house, if not quite ready for public outings. The Robben Shirt, by contrast, was oversized enough that our reviewer suggested it as a sleeping shirt instead.
A Jacket Built for a Tricky Body Type
Thin waist, long arms — a combination that's normally hard to fit off the rack. The Timor Jacket nailed sleeve length while staying trim through the midsection.
We Recommend This To Readers Who:
-
Have a hard-to-fit build
The Timor Jacket nailed sleeve length while staying trim through the midsection, solving a fit problem our reviewer said is usually hard to find.
-
Want a low-effort way to try new styles
The William Zip-Up Hoodie's unconventional two-tone sleeves worked despite being outside our reviewer's comfort zone.
A Closer Look
A Strong Second Box, One Miss Aside
Club 54's second box nailed the jacket, hoodie, and joggers, and even one oversized shirt wasn't enough to outweigh being cheaper than shopping in stores.
