Prized Pet Review
It’s More Than Just An Online Pet Store
I always worry that I am going to get ripped off by subscription boxes but this one was great.
Our reviewerA Small Store With A Big Price Advantage
Prized Pet set out looking like just another online pet store, but a search for TreatSimple sweet potato fries turned into a deeper dig through its catalog of treats and toys — smaller than the big chains, but well curated.
The standout discovery was price: TreatSimple treats, which aren't cheap when bought directly, showed up on Prized Pet at roughly a third of the cost, a real savings for anyone who already buys that brand.
The $16.99 monthly Prized Pet Box (shipping included) bundles a random 8-ounce treat, a 5-ounce treat, and a meat or chew treat. The test box brought Teriyaki beef bites from Lucky Dog, Bowwow Snicker Doodles from Paws Bakery, and a BarkWorthies Rabbit Roll — the rabbit roll was the runaway favorite with our tester's dog.
Every item ships from the US, and between the treats' individual retail prices, the box comfortably beats what it would cost to buy each item separately, before even factoring in free shipping.
The store itself still feels like a startup — the catalog is a little sparse and its healthier snacks cost more than mass-market ones — but for a low-risk way to discover new treats each month, Prized Pet delivers.
Why We Love It
- Inexpensive, quality dog treats
- $16.99 box is a low-cost way to discover new treats
- Every item is made in the US
Considerations
- Healthy snacks cost more than mass-market treats
- Store catalog is still fairly sparse
- Update (dead-destination-sweep-2026-07): our affiliate link for this specific offer is currently down (the tracking/redirect no longer resolves to the merchant), so treat the code/offer above as unconfirmed until it's restored -- we're leaving the page up rather than deleting it.
Our Hands-On Review
We went in looking for a specific TreatSimple product and came out having tested a full month's box instead — a random assortment, but every item felt deliberately chosen rather than filler.
The test box's three items ranged from $1.55 to $7.50 individually, and our tester's dog approved of all three, with the BarkWorthies Rabbit Roll disappearing fastest.
A Subscription Box Worth The Price
Between the three treats in the box, the individual retail value alone made the $16.99 monthly price feel like a fair trade — with shipping folded in.
We Recommend This To Readers Who:
-
Already buy TreatSimple
Prized Pet has carried it for roughly a third of the direct price.
-
Want a low-cost way to try new treats
The $16.99 monthly box bundles three items, shipping included.
-
Prioritize US-made treats
Everything in the box and store ships from the US.
A Closer Look
Investment in Treats
A single subscription price covers the whole monthly box, shipping included.
| Option | Price |
|---|---|
| Prized Pet Box (Monthly)Popular | $16.99 |
Good to Know
A Smart, Low-Risk Way To Discover New Treats
Prized Pet undercuts retail prices on treats like TreatSimple and wraps a genuine surprise into every $16.99 monthly box — a small catalog is the only real trade-off.
